Rank-discounting as a resolution to a dilemma in population ethics - HAL-SHS - Sciences de l'Homme et de la Société Accéder directement au contenu
Autre Publication Scientifique Année : 2017

Rank-discounting as a resolution to a dilemma in population ethics

Résumé

When evaluating well-being distributions in an anonymous (and replication invariant) manner, one faces a dilemma between (i) assigning dictatorship to a single worst-off person, thus succumbing to a tyranny of non-aggregation and (ii) assigning dictatorship to (unboundedly) many better-off persons, thus succumbing to a tyranny of aggregation. We show how this corresponds to a population-ethical dilemma in the variable population setting between, on the one hand, a reversed repugnant conclusion (preferring a very small population with high well-being) and, on the other hand, a repugnant conclusion (preferring a sufficiently large population with lives barely worth living to a population with good lives) or very sadistic conclusion (not preferring a large population with lives worth living to a population with terrible lives). The dilemma can be resolved by relaxing replication invariance and thus allowing that evaluation in the fixed population setting might change with population size even though the relative distributions of well-being remain unchanged. Rank-dependent criteria are evaluation criteria that resolve this dilemma but fails replication invariance. We provide conditions under which rank-dependent criteria are the only way our of the dilemma. Furthermore, we discuss the following perspective of the relaxation of replication invariance: It becomes important to associate with the notion of total population not the people that are alive at any one time, but the people that will ever live.
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
17041.pdf (746.42 Ko) Télécharger le fichier
Origine : Fichiers produits par l'(les) auteur(s)
Loading...

Dates et versions

halshs-01599532 , version 1 (02-10-2017)
halshs-01599532 , version 2 (28-11-2018)

Identifiants

  • HAL Id : halshs-01599532 , version 1

Citer

Geir B Asheim, Stéphane Zuber. Rank-discounting as a resolution to a dilemma in population ethics. 2017. ⟨halshs-01599532v1⟩
214 Consultations
216 Téléchargements

Partager

Gmail Facebook X LinkedIn More