Antisocial Attitudes, Gender and Moral Judgments: An Experimental Study

Juergen Bracht (1) , Adam Zylbersztejn (2)

1 University of Aberdeen
2 GATE - Groupe d'analyse et de théorie économique

We study questionnaire responses to moral dilemmas hypothetical situations in which sacrificing one life may save many other lives. We demonstrate gender differences in moral judgments: male participants are more supportive of the sacrifice than female participants. We investigate the importance of the previously studied source of the endorsement of the sacrfice: antisocial attitudes. First, we elicit the individual proneness to spiteful behavior using an incentivized experimental game. We demonstrate that spitefulness can be sizable but it is not associated with gender. Second, we find that gender is associated with moral judgments even when we account for individual differences in antisocial attitudes. Our results suggest that the performance of many institutions (related to the distribution of wealth or punishment, for instance) may be affected by the gender of the decision-makers. Abstract We study questionnaire responses to moral dilemmas hypothetical situations in which sacric-ing one life may save many other lives. We demonstrate gender dierences in moral judgments: male participants are more supportive of the sacrice than female participants. We investigate the importance of the previously studied source of the endorsement of the sacrice: antisocial attitudes. First, we elicit the individual proneness to spiteful behavior using an incentivized experimental game. We demonstrate that spitefulness can be sizable but it is not associated with gender. Second, we nd that gender is associated with moral judgments even when we account for individual dierences in antisocial attitudes. Our results suggest that the performance of many institutions (related to the distribution of wealth or punishment, for instance) may be aected by the gender of the decision-makers.

Mots clés: gender; moral dilemmas; moral judgments; spite; antisocial attitudes; experiment

Domaines: Economies et finances

Juergen Bracht, Adam Zylbersztejn. Antisocial Attitudes, Gender and Moral Judgments: An Experimental Study. Université Paris 8, Dec 2016, Paris, France. ⟨halshs-01417152⟩