, Reframing the Debate against Nuclear Weapons 14 Most empirical data were collected by Rachel Polaud during the completion of her Ph.D. thesis on this topic, under my supervision. I am grateful to her for authorizing me to use her findings. I made additional interviews A8>?&% '0))*33##% *$% *6%, Oa F% Y*3(*6% 3(#% 0/746*S43*06, 2004.
, % 3(#% I:EAC5,% 3(#% Yb<
, 0'4'J% )4J% V#% U026B% *6%
, #%A8>?&k%VJ% 8l5kD,%R/*B7#$,%6jQ,%KLLa,%GPaF% % 17 For instance, on the IAEA website, a full-size section is devoted to an IAEA-NGO forum, 2004.
, Nuclear Verification and Nuclear Fuel Cycle " . 18 Interview, head, external relations, 1959.
, 0))*3)#63$, S43*06, pp.6-30
, #%46%*)@4'3%06%B#'*$*06%)4W*67D%46B%2@7/4B#%*3$%023'0)#$ Ka F%A0%3(#% %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 23 19 non-governmental organizations have formal consultative status with the IAEA. Twenty others have been
, 06$#f2#6'#,% :;<% #X@#
, Interview, director, division of information management, 2007.
, #% 30% )0/#% *63#
, Be it as it may, this is not yet the case For the moment, NGO working with or against the IAEA are mostly focusing on security issues. An example of this tendency is the inclusion of one NGO only (International Crisis Group) within the " High-Level Panel of Experts to Recommend Future Course for IAEA " 28 As long as specific nuclear issues will be considered as broader disarmament issues, NGO access to the IAEA will remain limited. Therefore, the potential benefits from the agency's regulation process are concealed behind its limited success in disarmament. This is particluarly obvious when rewiewing NGO statements about the IAEA. Comparison between the two partnerships A comparison between the two cases under review shows that some conditions must be met for an IGO/NGO partnership to succeed. The first condition is the focalization of the IGO. That the relationships between the atomic agency and NGO are less structured than is the case in commerce may be due to the larger range of problems discussed in the WTO compared to the specificity of the issues raised within the IAEA. Whereas experts involved in trade deregulation, intellectual property, drug patents, agricultural exports, and access to domestic services are %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 27 Interview, safeguards information analyst, countless, few scientists are able to understand atom. This discrepancy in topic may explain why the eldest organization of the two was the latest to be targeted by NGO, p.25, 2006.
, #+0@)#63F%>6%'0))#, /#43#B%e% 46B%+0'43#B%e%6#X3%30%I:EAC5F%:0%$2'(%B*"*$*06%0U%+4V0/%*$%B#V43#B%*6%3(#%/#4+)%0U%430), p.30
, % :;<% 0V34*6#B% $0)#% >;<% 30+#, pp.4-7
, <%30%:;<N%46B%46%#UU#'3*"#=#UU*'*#63%'063/*V23*06%HU/0)%:;<% 30% >;<NF% <6 Interview, head, non proliferation and policy making organs section, *#$% )4J% V#% %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 31 Interview, director, division of information management, p.32, 2008.